What do we do about (1) songs that already have fandoms on the AO3 but as the album not the song (ex. Seanan McGuire's Wicked Girls), and (2) songs where there's bunches of versions and we're not nominating any particular version (ex. "Star of the County Down", "Tam Lin")? Looks like "Cartography" and "Snow Queen Dreams" off Wicked Girls are individual fandoms (though someone's declared "Jack's Place" and "Carnival Glass" characters—yes, I realize one of those is my fault), so I just nominate my four others off that album as individual fandoms? "Tam Lin" already has a fandom, I see (maybe I should scrap it in favor of SJ Tucker's "Poem of War"), do I want "Tam Lin & Related Works" or "Tam Lin (Traditional Ballad)"? Do I nominate "Star of the County Down" as "Star of the County Down (Song)"?
My planned noms (listing both "Tam Lin" and "Poem of War" because I dunno which I'm doing):
![[community profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/community.png){kind=small}
![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png){kind=small}
no subject
Date: 2013-07-25 05:09 am (UTC)What do we do about (1) songs that already have fandoms on the AO3 but as the album not the song (ex. Seanan McGuire's Wicked Girls), and (2) songs where there's bunches of versions and we're not nominating any particular version (ex. "Star of the County Down", "Tam Lin")? Looks like "Cartography" and "Snow Queen Dreams" off Wicked Girls are individual fandoms (though someone's declared "Jack's Place" and "Carnival Glass" characters—yes, I realize one of those is my fault), so I just nominate my four others off that album as individual fandoms? "Tam Lin" already has a fandom, I see (maybe I should scrap it in favor of SJ Tucker's "Poem of War"), do I want "Tam Lin & Related Works" or "Tam Lin (Traditional Ballad)"? Do I nominate "Star of the County Down" as "Star of the County Down (Song)"?
My planned noms (listing both "Tam Lin" and "Poem of War" because I dunno which I'm doing):
"Crossroads", Bekah Kelso (buy, lyrics)
"Shee An Gannon", The CRAIC (listen, lyrics)
"How Much Salt?", Seanan McGuire (lyrics, buy)
"Mother of the Crows", Seanan McGuire (lyrics, buy)
"My Story Is Not Done", Seanan McGuire (lyrics, buy)
"The True Story Here", Seanan McGuire (lyrics, buy)
"Star of the County Down", traditional (lyrics, alternate lyrics, buy umpty-ump versions, I'm fond of the Celtic Harvest version which here are the people to contact about buying their CD because why should they make it easy?)
"Tam Lin", traditional (lyrics of Fairport Convention's version, alternate lyrics, buy umpty-ump versions including Fairport Convention's)
"Poem of War", SJ Tucker (lyrics and listen and buy)